The Edmonton Oilers are a quarter of the way into the 2026-27 season, and on a macro level, things couldn’t be going much better for the team that’s atop the NHL standings.
Despite a rash of injuries to the supporting cast and an underperforming depth group, the Oilers have cruised to a 16-3-3 record and still haven’t lost on the road in regulation.
In terms of individual performances, two groups stand out as the driving forces behind that surge: Edmonton’s superstars are producing at historic levels, and — more shockingly — its goaltending ranks among the league’s very best.
The rest? Well, there are encouraging signs that a few are starting to find their footing, while others still have plenty to prove.
So, through the first quarter of the season, let’s do some grading to break down the credit for Edmonton’s hot start.
Grades are assigned based on performance, considering both expectations and salary. Those who have played 10 games or fewer were not included, leaving out Max Jones, Filip Hållander, Josh Samanski and Matt Tomkins.
Goaltending
Devon Levi — A
It’s beginning to look like general manager Stan Bowman fleeced the Buffalo Sabres. After shaking off a rocky season debut against the Vancouver Canucks, Levi has posted an 8-1-0 record, a 1.98 goals-against average and a .927 save percentage. Coming off his first career shutout under the bright lights of Saturday night hockey in Toronto, the 24-year-old looks every bit like the goalie of the future Buffalo thought it was getting when it acquired him for Sam Reinhart.
Tristan Jarry — A
Much like Levi, Jarry has largely erased the memory of his disastrous season debut against Vancouver. Since Oct. 10, he has posted a 6-1-2 record alongside a 2.07 goals-against average and .928 save percentage, with back-to-back shutouts on the New York-area trip. While he’s certainly benefiting from a vastly improved defensive structure, his disappointing 2025-26 campaign is looking far more like an aberration than a new normal.
The Hockey 100: Wayne Gretzky is No. 1 for a reason
Dan Robson and more
Defence
Evan Bouchard — A-plus
Averaging 1.64 points per game, Bouchard is on pace for the highest-scoring season by a defenceman since Paul Coffey erupted for 138 points in 79 games in 1985-86. Beyond leading all blueliners in every major offensive category by a wide margin, he has noticeably cleaned up his defensive game, helping Edmonton outscore opponents 36-9 at five-on-five. Right now, he should be the clear Norris Trophy front-runner.
Mattias Ekholm — A-minus
Playing the vast majority of his minutes next to Bouchard, the 36-year-old Ekholm has kept any age-related concerns at bay. Logging over 21 minutes per game against top competition, the steady Swede has chipped in 10 points through 20 games and is third in the NHL with a staggering plus-27 rating.
Ryan Shea — B-plus
Shea has looked like a home-run free-agent signing. Carrying a modest $4 million cap hit, he has logged more minutes than any Oiler not named Bouchard. Between his smooth skating, crisp zone exits, sharp outlet passes and underrated physical edge, he has been entrusted with a frontline role that includes first-unit penalty-kill duty and second-unit power-play time. His only issue so far might be his partner — Edmonton owns just a 33 percent goal share (42 percent xG) with Shea and Connor Murphy paired together, compared to 75 percent (57 percent xG) when Shea plays away from him.
Ty Emberson — B-minus
For a No. 6/7 defenceman, Emberson is doing what Mike Babcock expects of him. With his ice time hovering around 12 minutes per game, the 26-year-old has largely stayed out of the coach’s highlight reel of mistakes while delivering close to break-even five-on-five numbers. He won’t wow anyone with his puck-moving, but his simplicity and positional reliability have kept him firmly ahead of Walman in the lineup.
Shakir Mukhamadullin — C
There’s no getting around Mukhamadullin’s brutal start. In the first weeks of the season, the 6-foot-5 defender was being outmuscled around the net and responsible for some egregious turnovers. Since Babcock settled on him and Emberson as the third pair, the results have been somewhat palatable.
Connor Murphy — C-minus
Unlike his partner, Murphy hasn’t been good enough this season. Offence has never been his calling card, so a lone assist through 22 games would be easy to overlook if he were rock solid defensively. Instead, the opposite has been true. Alongside Shea, Murphy owns a 33 percent five-on-five goal share, and away from him, that figure plummets to a ghastly 14 percent (21 percent xG). Now 33, he appears to have lost a step and has struggled to defend the rush, and while his physicality remains an asset, it hasn’t translated into consistent defensive results.
Jake Walman — F
Walman has easily been the Oilers’ most disappointing player. Coming off a subpar 2025-26 campaign, expectations were high for the 30-year-old entering Year 1 of his seven-year, $49 million contract extension. Few could have foreseen him sitting out as a healthy scratch eight times through Edmonton’s first 22 games. After getting burned repeatedly by Vancouver in the opening two games of the season and again by the Toronto Maple Leafs on Oct. 24, he appears to have completely lost Babcock’s trust.
Forwards
Connor McDavid — A-plus
No surprises here for a generational talent accomplishing feats only exceeded by Wayne Gretzky. On the heels of tying Gretzky’s 1984-85 mark for the fewest games needed to hit 40 assists (22), McDavid has racked up 53 points and owns the same number of assists as the NHL’s second-leading scorer, Draisaitl, has total points (41). Averaging nearly 24 minutes per game and finding the scoresheet in every single game so far, he is playing at the absolute height of his powers.
Leon Draisaitl — A-plus
With 20 goals through 22 games, Draisaitl is pacing for 76 tallies — putting him squarely on track to top Auston Matthews’ 69-goal 2023-24 campaign, which would stand as the greatest goal-scoring season of the 21st century. Converting on more than 23 percent of his shots, the 31-year-old has been nothing short of automatic. McDavid couldn’t handpick a better wingman to finish his passes.
Vasily Podkolzin — A
Podkolzin entered the season with lofty expectations for himself after recording career-high offensive totals alongside Draisaitl last year. He’s lived up to them, putting up 10 goals and 16 points through 22 games. While he’s cooled off — managing just two points in his last eight games, partly due to reduced power-play time with the returns of Ryan Nugent-Hopkins and Zach Hyman — Podkolzin continues to be a perfect stylistic fit on the top line. His relentless work on the forecheck meshes seamlessly with Edmonton’s new dump-and-chase system.
Ryan Nugent-Hopkins — B
For the time being, the 2011 No. 1 pick has held his own centring Edmonton’s second line. Nugent-Hopkins continues to be a fixture on the top power-play unit, racking up seven of his 11 points with the man advantage. At even strength, however, he is merely breaking even in goal share while getting slightly outchanced, raising fair questions about whether he is a viable long-term answer in that high-leverage role — particularly as he remains a liability in the faceoff circle (46.7 percent).
Mathieu Joseph — B
For a low-cost free-agent signing virtually nobody talked about, Joseph has delivered strong value for the Oilers. Not only does he rank among Edmonton’s best penalty killers (3.61 GA/60) — a unit where he should likely be utilized even more — he has also chipped in eight points through 22 games, which is solid for a bottom-six forward. While injuries have frequently pushed him onto the third line, he has shown he will be an ideal energy winger on the fourth unit once the roster is fully healthy.
Kasperi Kapanen — B-minus
Kapanen is one of the Oilers’ most versatile forwards. He can just as easily handle third-line and penalty-kill duty as he can jump onto the second line or the top power-play unit. Armed with the prerequisite skill to hang alongside McDavid and Draisaitl in a pinch, he also leans on his speed and defensive-zone awareness to be an effective short-handed option. Still, he hasn’t quite gotten the job done at five-on-five, where Edmonton holds just a 39 percent goal share (11-7 against, 45 percent xG) with him on the ice.
Zach Hyman — B-minus
Hyman was dealt a tough hand to start the season, battling two separate injuries and initially struggling to find his rhythm. Still, nobody can question the 34-year-old’s dogged work on the forecheck, and that persistence is starting to pay off. He scored two goals against the Philadelphia Flyers on home ice last week and added another in Sunday’s rematch on the road for good measure.
Colton Dach — B-minus
Dach has been an early surprise. After opening the season miscast as a fourth-line centre due to injuries down the middle, he has found a much better home in the middle six as an abrasive, hard-to-play-against checking winger. While five points in 16 games leaves room for more production, he has shown flashes of self-created skill that don’t depend on linemates doing the work for him — attacking the net with authority and never shying away from a confrontation.
Jason Dickinson — C+
Having played just 13 games, evaluating Dickinson is still slightly premature, though his game is gradually coming along. While the Oilers are surely hoping he can get closer to the offensive production he flashed in the playoffs, his biggest impact so far has come on a revitalized penalty kill (5.56 GA/60). At five-on-five, the picture is more complicated. He has yet to be burned on the scoreboard (0.48 GA/60), but his 29 percent expected-goals share — tied with Owen Michaels for worst on the team — suggests he is spending far too much time defending.
Isaac Howard — C-minus
Right off the bat, it became clear Babcock didn’t view 22-year-old Howard as a top-six option. For a player who has always produced in a frontline role at lower levels, judging him on an average of 8:53 per game on the fourth line feels almost unproductive. Still, he hasn’t won enough puck battles, and his play away from the puck clearly needs work. Keeping his feet moving alone won’t translate to NHL success. Howard suffered a knee injury on Halloween, and upon his activation from injured reserve Monday, he was loaned by the Oilers to AHL Bakersfield.
Owen Michaels — D
As Babcock put it, Michaels opened training camp on the “eighth line.” Because he wasn’t in the coaching staff’s plans whatsoever, everything he accomplished early on felt like pure gravy. Two goals in his first three contests and a string of faceoff wins briefly had him looking like Edmonton’s top bottom-six forward. But overall, the Oilers have been outscored 13-5 in his five-on-five minutes, proving he could use some AHL seasoning. Yet as the Oilers’ lone right-shot centre, he stays.
Trent Frederic — D
Frederic is another player who is difficult to evaluate given his usage. Babcock has made him a healthy scratch three times already, signalling some doubt about his ability to execute the new system effectively. Whether or not Frederic has been unfairly singled out, one goal and zero assists through 19 games puts him on an even worse scoring pace than last year’s seven-point campaign. To his credit, he is at least breaking even during his minutes.
Alex Formenton — D
Expectations weren’t all that high for a player who hadn’t suited up in an NHL game since 2022. Given that Formenton has remained in the lineup for every game, however, he hasn’t quite held up his end. Although his play against Toronto and Philadelphia this weekend was some of his best all year, that brief spark hasn’t erased a mostly invisible, replacement-level start to the season.



