Inside Newcastle Q&A: Jaissle’s point to prove, Toure and Bamba game time, Wilson future

onesport
15 Min Read
Disclosure: This website may contain affiliate links, which means I may earn a commission if you click on the link and make a purchase. I only recommend products or services that I personally use and believe will add value to my readers. Your support is appreciated!

During the Premier League season, The Athletic’s Newcastle United subscribers can ask our writers covering the club for their views and insight into what’s happening at St James’ Park.

We have pulled together some of the questions and our answers from Monday’s edition of our Inside Newcastle live Q&A, which included queries about Bazoumana Toure and Aladji Bamba’s lack of game time, whether Matthias Jaissle is ‘Jesse Marsch 2.0’ and the lack of a No 10 within the squad.

Want to ask us anything Newcastle-related? Chris Waugh will be back soon for another session.


I’d love a bit more detail on the assessment of Bazoumana Toure and Aladji Bamba. What exactly is missing from their game that means they aren’t ready to start? — Colin S

Waugh: The key point with Bamba and Toure is that they were not Jaissle signings. Eddie Howe was not convinced either was necessarily ready for the here and now either — he did sanction the purchase of Toure and liked his attributes, but felt he would take longer to adapt than the initial target, who was Victor Munoz — and they were both back-up options. Bamba joined during the crossover period between when the club knew Howe was leaving and before Jaissle was appointed, so Ross Wilson, the sporting director, played a key role his purchase.

There was a telling moment during Jaissle’s pre-Fulham press conference when he sought clarity on a question about the game time of summer additions, and asked whether the reporter was referring to “my signings”. The messaging was that, of the three players he pushed to be brought in (Amar Dedic, Nico Gonzalez and Matias Fernandez-Pardo), as well as Lukas Hornicek, who was already a target but Jaissle sanctioned, all have played regularly. Bamba, Toure and, to a lesser degree, Sean Steur have featured less, and all joined before the head coach arrived.

Bazoumana Toure has played just 118 minutes in the Premier League so far (Paul Ellis / AFP via Getty Images)

With Toure, there is a feeling the 20-year-old winger remains raw. He is exciting and direct, but his decision-making is unreliable and his end product variable (though the latter point hardly differs from many current starters). More of an issue is his off-the-ball work. Physically, he needs to build robustness and his defensive discipline and tracking of his runner must improve.

As for Bamba, the 20-year-old is also viewed as ‘green’, which is unsurprising given he had less than half a season’s worth of first-team experience at Monaco before joining. Although well over 6ft tall, Bamba remains slight and it will take him time to develop the physical and athletic, as well as technical, requirements necessary to succeed in the Premier League. Even though Joelinton and Jacob Ramsey are currently out injured, Bamba did not make the Fulham matchday squad.

Both are huge talents, though, and much is expected of them. But to spend a combined £72million ($96.5m) on the pair during a summer in which Newcastle lost so many first-XI players, and for Jaissle to deem neither as ready to contribute regularly, suggests those funds could have been better invested elsewhere for the short-to-medium term. In time, they may become quality players for Newcastle, but Jaissle needs players who can perform now, too.


Have we considered other options as No 10? Jacob Ramsey played a wide 10 role at Villa? — Ross H

Waugh: Ramsey does seem like a strong candidate for the No 10 role and I’ve been surprised by his lack of opportunities there, having predicted shortly after Jaissle arrived that the 25-year-old would be fielded there.

Injuries and his recent (brainless) suspension have limited his opportunities but, aside from a couple of short cameos as a No 10 as a substitute, Ramsey has been used primarily as an orthodox midfielder. During his youth career, that was where Ramsey often played but, having been regularly deployed as a left-sided No 10 under Unai Emery at Aston Villa, Howe set about converting him back into a midfielder.

So far, Jaissle does not seem to fancy Ramsey as a Premier League starter, regardless of position. He is yet to start in the league and Yoane Wissa and Joe Willock have been sharing the No 10 responsibilities. Now that Fernandez-Pardo is fit, I suspect the Belgian will also get game time there, or Will Osula may shift deeper, potentially pushing Ramsey further down the pecking order.

That is contingent on Jaissle sticking with this system, mind. Given his lack of a natural No 10, it may make sense for Jaissle to (belatedly) switch formations and play with a three-man midfield, instead.

Regardless, it is up to Ramsey to prove he can be that creative player in the No 10 position and that he warrants a regular starting place. So far throughout his Newcastle career, he has flattered to deceive and has never really grasped his chance.

(Stu Forster/Getty Images)


Was it a mistake to go for Fernandez-Pardo instead of El Khannouss, a No 10? — Blaise I

Waugh: While it is too early to be determining whether recruiting Fernandez-Pardo ahead of El Khannouss was a “mistake”, I do think the failure to acquire a specialist No 10 has left Jaissle hamstrung. The head coach needs to accept his own share of the responsibility there because he advocated moving for Fernandez-Pardo, but Wilson and the recruitment team were also aware of Jaissle’s preference to play a 4-2-3-1 formation and yet did not bring in a player to field in that second-striker position.

Howe never wanted an out-and-out No 10, even if that sometimes left his team short of guile and creativity, and he usually played a system which did not require one. Jaissle, however, does prefer to deploy a 4-2-3-1 and the lack of ingenuity being offered by those being played out of position in the No 10 role has really affected Newcastle’s offensive patterns (and made them even more vulnerable defensively, given their lack of familiarity with the necessary off-the-ball positioning).

El Khannous is liked by Newcastle and was also looked at during the summer of 2025, though perhaps the club held reservations about whether he would be a success on Tyneside. There were a paucity of alternative quality No 10 options, so that provides some mitigation, though it remains puzzling that Newcastle appointed a head coach who plays a 4-2-3-1 formation and did not sign a No 10 after five years of not acquiring one under Howe.


Is Jaissle just Jesse Marsch v2.0 (to coin a favoured NUFC business strategy term)? – Anonymous P

Waugh: The detractors of the Red Bull school of coaching, especially those in England, would recognise your (I assume) derogatory comparison. Both came through the Red Bull system, with Jaissle actually succeeding Marsch at Red Bull Salzburg, and they believe in “vertical” football.

Those who regularly watched Marsch’s Leeds United claim the American was also keen for his team to go direct and go long regularly, and they preferred a narrow attacking system, rather than using wingers to provide width. There are definite echoes in Jaissle’s game plan, as you would expect given their shared education, though both have adopted subtly different interpretations of vertical football.

Over this international break, The Athletic intends to explore more about Jaissle’s philosophy and attempt to uncover what it is he wants to achieve with his Newcastle side. For those supporters who are already losing faith in his ‘project’, Jaissle needs to demonstrate that his principles and style can succeed in the Premier League — and that his players can and want to adopt them.

As of yet, Jaissle’s inability to demonstrate a clear identity has been one of his greatest shortcomings. Even if results had been similar but the style of play had been discernible, then greater patience may well have been shown by some supporters.

(Clive Mason/Getty Images)


Is this what a season of transition looks like to you or do you think it’s worse than that? — Felix S

Waugh: Jaissle repeating that this is a “transitional season” has been a smart move because there is no set definition of what that should look like. As long as Newcastle are not relegated, he could theoretically argue that any other finishing position reflects that period of change and adjustment.

More of an issue for Jaissle — and for the hierarchy — were the more positive remarks offered by Wilson and David Hopkinson, the CEO, once the window closed. Neither promised Europe or a trophy, but they did speak optimistically about what could be achieved and, in Wilson’s case, insisted that the summer had gone to “plan” (barring the sale of Bruno Guimaraes). Those comments arguably inflated expectations, especially given they came after a promising start during which Newcastle collected five points from their first three games, and perhaps did not psychologically prepare supporters well enough for the bumpy campaign to come.

My prediction has always been that Newcastle could finish anywhere from seventh to 14th and that has not changed. Newcastle are currently 12th with 12 points from 10 games and three wins, three draws and four defeats is a fair reflection of their start.

Last season Newcastle finished 12th and so a similar placing would not be disastrous in that sense. Yet Newcastle’s growth plan relies upon European revenues and so, if they do not qualify for UEFA competition for next season, then that could have a damaging effect on future budgets. Even so, economic need does not always align with fair footballing expectation and that is likely to be the case for Newcastle this season.


Is Ross Wilson’s position under threat? One website claimed it was, but I haven’t seen anything from anywhere else suggesting this is the case. Either way, the summer transfer business seems to have been incredibly naive — Tom L

Waugh: I saw the report, but I’ve had nothing to corroborate that. Instead, those at the top of the club continue to project a unified front and remain confident in their overarching blueprint. Wilson and Hopkinson worked in tandem over the summer and opted to bring in Jaissle; as The Athletic wrote last week, they are still convinced by the head coach and are hopeful recent player additions will start delivering more soon.

That does not mean PIF (Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment Fund, Newcastle’s majority owners) and the Reubens (the minority stakeholders) are not watching closely. Jacobo Solis, the director, was on Tyneside last week and, as well as attending Jaissle’s press conferences and multiple matches, the PIF official spoke to various figures across the club, including Hopkinson and Wilson (who he is in daily contact with anyway). Newcastle insisted Solis’ visit was entirely routine, though the director being present while the team were struggling and disquiet was growing among supporters felt timely.

A sporting director should not be judged just two months after a window, nor really should they be judged on one window alone. Their role is longer-term and more holistic and Wilson has been longing to implement changes across the club. Yet spending more than £300m — albeit while recouping £240m as well — means scrutiny will arrive if results are not going well. And not just from supporters, but from above, too.


(NOTE: Readers using our app on an Android device may need to use two fingers to scroll through the survey. Still unable to get to the survey, though? Try this direct link)

Source link

Share This Article
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *